Customer Reviews
Average Customer Review
(14 customer reviews) 10 of 10 people found the following review helpful
Best Thanksgiving Turkey Ever,
December 14, 2007 Jillian L. Davis (New Hampshire USA) - See all my reviews
This review is from: Bayou Classic 7417 12-Quart Cast-Iron Oval Roaster with Domed Lid (Lawn & Patio)
This pan (After a lot of cleaning and seasoning) made the best Thanksgiving Turkey ever... It was moist and perfect and a few guests told me it was the best they had ever had. I had never used Bayou as I love Lodge but they did not offer a roaster in this size (needed something for a 18lb turkey that JUST fit.) The quality of the cast iron was OK and needed more seasoning than a lodge that are pre seasoned but it did a GREAT JOB... I have cooked 2 small chickens in it and they were great as well...
6 of 6 people found the following review helpful
Who needs quality control?,
June 28, 2008 Ellen M. Thayer (Crownsville, MD USA) - See all my reviews
This review is from: Bayou Classic 7417 12-Quart Cast-Iron Oval Roaster with Domed Lid (Lawn & Patio)
After reading the other reviews I was a bit skeptical, but the problems seemed associated only with the inadequate packaging for shipping. With Amazon's free shipping, I thought I would just have them send me a replacement if necessary.
The unit arrived without shipping damage. But it contained a large crack which was due to the original casting operation. Also the cover didn't fit. I decided to try ordering the Camp Chef to see if that was any better.
On the packing slip, it states that the S&H was over $26. Amazon must be losing money on just shipping this unit, let alone having to pay for the return shipment via USPS! I can't believe that Amazon doesn't either pull the product or make Bayou Classic fix their horrendous QC problems.
4 of 4 people found the following review helpful
You can do it all,
December 27, 2007 S. Eason (McKinney, TX) - See all my reviews
Amazon Verified Purchase(What's this?)
This review is from: Bayou Classic 7417 12-Quart Cast-Iron Oval Roaster with Domed Lid (Lawn & Patio)
With this cast iron roaster you can do it all. I use it in the oven, over a fire, in a fire, on the cooktop, in a gas grill, over propane flames, etc. We used it for fryin fish, cooking biscuits, roasting pot roast, baking cakes, and on and on. It is very heavy, so be warned. But you can used it everywhere to cook nearly anything.